Handmade Fudge

Over 160 different kinds of small batch, handmade fudge crafted to date.

Oh Fudge! Better than Grandma’s and fresh from our kettle. Made from real butter, cream, and superior ingredients. Our fudge master has made over 160 different kinds of fudge to date. You can also find our fudge at these Colorado locations: Brown Dog Coffee in Buena Vista and Salida, Mount Princeton Hot Springs Resort in Nathrop, The Local Market in Breckenridge, and Salida Pharmacy and Fountain.

CHECK OUT THESE TOP FLAVORS

BUTTERSCOTCH ESPRESSO

Butterscotch mixed with espresso in a yummy, coffee-ish delight. If you like coffee you’ll love this. If you like Butterscotch and coffee… you will be in fudge heaven!

Homemade fudge - Stedman's - Buena Vista, CO

CHEWY PRALINE

The ice cream is great…. but not as good as this! No kidding, this is the chewiest, praline-iest, yummiest taste you’ll ever have. Don’t blame us if you are addicted after one bite!

CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER

Those other guys who think they know how to make a great combination have nothing on us! Ours is fine and smooth! Go ahead. Order it. You’ll thank us later.

CHOCOLATE PECAN AND CHOCOLATE WALNUT

If you like a bit of “crunch” to your chocolate then this is the fudge for you. Walnut or Pecan? You choose. Can’t go wrong either way.

CLASSIC CHOCOLATE

Do we need to say any more? This is the epitome of what people think of when they hear the word “fudge.” Smooth, chocolatey, yumminess. What are you waiting for?

DARK CHOCOLATE CARAMEL SEA SALT

This one is amazing and one of our best sellers. The combination of chocolate, sea salt, and caramel is a winner all the way around. If you’re a chocolate lover, watch out! After eating this one you won’t want anything else.

Homemade fudge - Stedman's - Buena Vista, CO

DARK CHOCOLATE MINT

What can we say except you will not be disappointed with this classic combination of dark chocolate and mint. A melt-in-your mouth experience worthy of all that is ‘just plain’ good!

MAPLE NUT

Maple Nut is an all-around favorite. That north-eastern maple flavor combined with the nutty texture and taste of, well… nuts! Get some!

TIGER BUTTER

Yummy vanilla, creamy peanut butter, and rich chocolate all stacked together in a fantastical way that makes your mouth go — YES!

VANILLA CARAMEL SEA SALT

The sweetness of caramel is highlighted by the salt taste of the sea (sea salt, get it) to bring you the best bite your mouth has experienced in a very long time. Don’t eat too much. Never mind. Go ahead.

search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close